In a recent appearance on the ABC Nightline series, Identity Denied: Trans in America, Rachel Levine, the highest-ranking openly transgender federal official in the United States, shed light on a sensitive and complex issue affecting some American children. Levine emphasized that adolescence and puberty can be challenging for everyone, but for some, the experience is compounded by the feeling of going through the “wrong puberty.” As a transgender individual herself, Levine’s insights have brought to the forefront a discussion about gender-affirming care and the challenges faced by transgender youths.
“Adolescence is hard and puberty is hard. What if you’re going through the wrong puberty? What if you inside feel that you are female, but now you’re going through a male puberty?” Levine questioned, expressing the inner turmoil experienced by some young individuals struggling with their gender identity.
Levine acknowledged that there are concerns from some quarters about children engaging in sex-related interventions at a young age. The argument is that children might be too young to fully understand their gender identity. Levine responded to these concerns by clarifying that for prepubertal children, no medical procedures are performed. Instead, the standard of care allows them to explore their gender identity through therapy, providing a safe and supportive environment for self-discovery.
It is essential to note that Levine, who is now serving as an Assistant Secretary for Health, did not transition until adulthood, specifically at the age of 54 in 2011. This information has led some to question whether Levine can truly understand the experiences of young transgender individuals who are grappling with their identity during their formative years.
Addressing the issue of gender-affirming care, Levine made the statement, asserting that it is not only medical care but also mental health care and a form of suicide prevention. The words carry significant weight, especially considering the high rates of mental health challenges and suicide attempts among transgender youths.
Despite Levine’s expertise and personal experience, there have been critics who question the necessity of such interventions for young children. Some argue that individuals should wait until they reach the age of 18 before pursuing any sex-related procedures. Levine, however, stands firm in her belief that for some transgender youths, the struggle with puberty and gender identity cannot wait until adulthood.
“It is impossible to go through the wrong puberty, and he knows it,” commented one Twitter user, expressing skepticism about Levine’s statements. Others have gone further, condemning the concept of being “born in the wrong body” as harmful to children’s mental health and even likening it to abuse, with calls for legal consequences for parents who support such views.
Additionally, there are those who criticize Levine as a transgender official, viewing her as a source of embarrassment for the nation. Such sentiments highlight the polarized nature of discussions surrounding gender identity and healthcare, as well as the challenges faced by transgender individuals in positions of authority.
What do you think? Leave a comment below…